Go back
An idea for improving the “thumbs” feature

An idea for improving the “thumbs” feature

Site Ideas


@ponderable said
So how important is this in the bigger frame of things?
Absolutely nothing at RHP is anywhere near the bigger frame of things. There's nothing wrong with doing little things that make this site better.


2 edits

If any individual (subscriber or not) is distressed over seeing a thumb count on his messages, why not allow them to disable it? For themselves that is, not for everyone else.
Some people are distressed by it and some aren't, so why not let everyone decide for themselves if they want to see an approval/disapproval rating?

I'm suggesting it could be made invisible only to the person who doesn't want to see it


@kilroy70 said
If any individual (subscriber or not) is distressed over seeing a thumb count on his messages, why not allow them to disable it? For themselves that is, not for everyone else.
Some people are distressed by it and some aren't, so why not let everyone decide for themselves if they want to see an approval/disapproval rating?

I'm suggesting it could be made invisible only to the person who doesn't want to see it
This suggestion was already made maybe a dozen pages ago. The interesting thing about making it possible for the recipient of thumbs to disable them [so that they alone don't see them] is that several of the supporters of the feature argue that it is a chance to send a message to the recipient.

1 edit

@fmf said
There's nothing wrong with doing little things that make this site better.
No, there's not.

But this "suggestion" will result in people making bad posting decisions getting less pushback about their bad posting decisions. One can easily see why you two, out of all the posters on this site, are the most vocal about either restricting the feature or making it not anonymous, so that you can easily endlessly berate those who disagree with you.

Because that IS what would happen. And everyone knows it.

And that would make this site and its forums worse, not better.


@fmf said
This suggestion was already made maybe a dozen pages ago.
It was already voted down a dozen pages or so. And yet, you and the goose are still yabbering on about it as if it were an honest suggestion.

Stop it, already. You have been weighted, and found wanting.




-Removed-
Apparently, you and your partner in crime are the only ones who got a vote.


-Removed-
Silencing pushback doesn't make people dislike your bad posting habits any less, either.




-Removed-
For starters, this one right here. It's tiresome and dishonest.



@suzianne said
Silencing pushback doesn't make people dislike your bad posting habits any less, either.
Anonymous thumbs ARE silenced "pushback". And if, as Kilroy70 suggests, it should be possible for the recipient to disable them, then they aren't "pushback" at all.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.