@humy said
So what? That confirms part of what I just said and is partly what I said and there is nothing there that contradicts what I just said.
Evaporation + condensation = hurricane
Evaporation only = no hurricane
So what? Are you saying a warmer world there wouldn't be more condensation as well as more evaporation? If so, extremely basic physics tells us otherwis ...[text shortened]... ndeed what is happening while you have failed to show links explaining any evidence to the contrary.
I am about to repeat myself again because you never listen. The tropic oceans are always warm during hurricane season. The warmth is always there during hurricane season.
If warmth of the water alone was enough there would be never ending hurricanes and PR would be uninhabitable during hurricane season. Fortunately this is not what causes hurricanes to form.
A colder upper atmosphere is the variable needed for a hurricane to form and that happens more often in a colder climate than a warm one. That is why hurricanes are more frequent in a colder climate and less in a warmer climate.
"Are you saying a warmer world there wouldn't be more condensation as well as more evaporation? If so, extremely basic physics tells us otherwise."
Yes, that is exactly what I am saying. Basic physics does NOT tell us otherwise. You are making crap up again.
You have been duped by yourself because of confirmation bias.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/science-choice/201504/what-is-confirmation-bias
"Once we have formed a view, we embrace information that confirms that view while ignoring, or rejecting, information that casts doubt on it. Confirmation bias suggests that we don’t perceive circumstances objectively. We pick out those bits of data that make us feel good because they confirm our prejudices."
"In sum, people are prone to believe what they want to believe. Seeking to confirm our beliefs comes naturally, while it feels strong and counterintuitive to look for evidence that contradicts our beliefs. This explains why opinions survive and spread. Disconfirming instances are far more powerful in establishing the truth. Disconfirmation would require looking for evidence to disprove it."
"For group decision-making, it is crucial to obtain information from each member in a way that they are independent. For example, as part of a police procedure to derive the most reliable information from multiple witnesses to a crime, witnesses are not allowed to discuss it prior to giving their testimony. The goal is to prevent unbiased witnesses from influencing each other. It is known that Abraham Lincoln intentionally filled his cabinet with rival politicians who had extremely different ideologies. When making decisions, Lincoln always encouraged vigorous debate and discussion."
You are claiming science says something it does not.
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/killer-hurricanes
Here is an excerpt from the link above:
NARRATOR: And looking even further back in time, scientists are discovering that 1,000 years ago, major Atlantic hurricanes may have struck more often.
The program goes on to confirm this.
"NARRATOR: But these findings present a puzzle. 1780, the year of the Great Hurricane, falls in the generally colder period of the Little Ice Age.
JEFF DONNELLY: It appears, at first flush, to be quite an anomaly that this 1780 season, and actually that a couple of decades around it, are actually one of the most active intervals.
NARRATOR: But as Jeff looked more closely at the sea surface temperatures, he was able to detect a brief but noticeable spike in the decades around 1780. And cool temperatures in the atmosphere above with warm ocean water below is a known ingredient for hurricane formation.
KERRY EMANUEL: And whenever you have two bodies of very different temperatures, you can create a lot of energy that way.
JEFF DONNELLY: So, that might explain why, in the middle of the Little Ice Age, we see, you know, an increase in hurricane activity."
Watch it before you make any more false assertions about science. Your links are gossip and nothing more. You accepted it because of confirmation bias.