Go back
Minor Debates, Easily Settled

Minor Debates, Easily Settled

General


-Removed-
No, just do it more effectively, after you've taken time to consider your own actions as well as those of others. Procrastination improves outcomes. Or it eliminates them.

1 edit

1 edit

-Removed-
Guess that piece of playing-the-man has settled that debate.
Anyone have a new bone?



@kewpie said
Guess that piece of playing-the-man has settled that debate.
Anyone have a new bone?
Did dinosaurs actually exist?

(At least twice in my life I've had to have this conversation,....with an adult).


@kewpie said
No, just do it more effectively, after you've taken time to consider your own actions as well as those of others. Procrastination improves outcomes. Or it eliminates them.
I think procrastination has a certain negative connotation. Attendant thereto, I think deliberation is the more positive counterpart to procrastination. The dictionary may not back me to the hilt but it's all about usage and our living language.


-Removed-
She said a NEW bone.


@kewpie said
You're right that "is" follows the implied singular "sum", but in fact the whole sentence is invalid.
Four and four are simply two nouns; try replacing them with any two other nouns. Cow and horse is/are livestock?
On the other hand, using symbols makes it a valid numerical statement. 4 + 4 = 8.
Beat me to it. Very nicely explained.


@ghost-of-a-duke said
Did dinosaurs actually exist?

(At least twice in my life I've had to have this conversation,....with an adult).
Yes they did exist but died out 6000 years ago.


1 edit

@kewpie said
try replacing them with any two other nouns. Cow and horse is/are livestock?
The language used to talk about arithmetic and numerals does not need to be the same as the language used to talk about livestock.

"A cow and a horse" is not an arithmetical sum and cow and horse are not numerals being added together in a sum.

Another way of looking at it is to recognize the implicit ellipsis: ["the sum of"] four and four is eight.

On the other hand, using symbols makes it a valid numerical statement. 4 + 4 = 8.

What I see when I look at "4 + 4 = 8" is "four plus four equals eight".

"Equals", conjugation: third person singular.

Certainly not "equal".

Perhaps it is a British or other dialect thing?


@fmf said
Perhaps it is a British thing?
Colchester United are on the attack: but Ipswich Town are holding on.

Colchester United is on the attack: but Ipswich Town is holding on.

Which construction sounds right to you in your part of the world?


@fmf said
Colchester United are on the attack: but Ipswich Town are holding on.

Colchester United is on the attack: but Ipswich Town is holding on.

Which construction sounds right to you in your part of the world?
Colchester United are on the attack: but Ipswich Town are holding on.


Ipswich Town win 6-0 sounds better.


@the-gravedigger said
Colchester United are on the attack: but Ipswich Town are holding on.
“These United States are ….” prior to 1863, but “The United States is …“ thereafter.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.