"Most violence is caused by mental illness"

Spirituality

08 Jun 22

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

1 edit

"Most violence is caused by mental illness".

If that statement were to be true, what would the implications be for the stance of religious people who assert that the level of violence in society is caused by moral decline?

A fun title

Scoffer Mocker

Joined: 27 Sep 06
Moves: 9958

08 Jun 22

@fmf said
"Most violence is caused by mental illness".

If that statement were to be true, what would the implications be for the stance of religious people who assert that the level of violence in society is caused by moral decline?

How do you define "violence"?

If "mental illness" was the cause of violence, then free will would cease to be a factor with regard to behavior, and accountability could not be assigned with punishment.

I think mental illness would be more apply assigned to anyone that thinks moral decline isn't the cause of violence.

And being "religious" isn't the cause of human conscience. One might ask whether the knowledge of right and wrong is designed innately into the human construct as is the heart beat, or if consciousness of morality is the product of training.

"Religion" is the product of training, but the conscience, with regards to right and wrong, is hard wired into the soul.

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

@josephw said
How do you define "violence"?

Define it as you wish.

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

@josephw said
I think mental illness would be more apply assigned to anyone that thinks moral decline isn't the cause of violence.

Really?

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

"In the United States, for example, violent crime rates have fallen by over 50% in many major U.S. cities since these rates peaked in the early 1990s, often referred to as the "Great Crime Decline". In New York City, these rates had dropped by 75% from the early 1990s to 2010." [wiki]

Was this "Great Crime Decline" linked in any way to an improvement in morality?

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

1 edit

https://www.mind.org.uk

Are mental health problems increasing?

The overall number of people reporting mental health problems has been going up in recent years.

The amount of people with common mental health problems went up by 20% between 1993 to 2014, in both men and women.

The percentage of people reporting severe mental health symptoms in any given week rose from 7% in 1993, to over 9% in 2014 .

The number of young women reporting common mental health problems has been going up

More relevant stuff

A fun title

Scoffer Mocker

Joined: 27 Sep 06
Moves: 9958

08 Jun 22

@fmf said
Define it as you wish.

Thanks. I'll define violence as sin in the context of this thread.

A fun title

Scoffer Mocker

Joined: 27 Sep 06
Moves: 9958

08 Jun 22

-1

@fmf said
Really?

Yes, really. Moral decline is at the root of why people violate their conscience and excuse their sin.

A fun title

Scoffer Mocker

Joined: 27 Sep 06
Moves: 9958

08 Jun 22

@fmf said
"In the United States, for example, violent crime rates have fallen by over 50% in many major U.S. cities since these rates peaked in the early 1990s, often referred to as the "Great Crime Decline". In New York City, these rates had dropped by 75% from the early 1990s to 2010." [wiki]

Was this "Great Crime Decline" linked in any way to an improvement in morality?

I doubt it.

Crime rates dropped as a result of increased law enforcement.

Or didn't you know that?

Or do you interpret the statistics in another way? Perhaps you're a statistician today after googling?

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

@josephw said
I think mental illness would be more apply assigned to anyone that thinks moral decline isn't the cause of violence.

So, anyone who thinks mental illness is a cause of violence - and not necessarily moral decline - should, according to you, have mental illness "assigned" to them?

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

@josephw said
Crime rates dropped as a result of increased law enforcement.

I agree that is a major factor.

A fun title

Scoffer Mocker

Joined: 27 Sep 06
Moves: 9958

08 Jun 22

@fmf said
https://www.mind.org.uk

Are mental health problems increasing?

The overall number of people reporting mental health problems has been going up in recent years.

The amount of people with common mental health problems went up by 20% between 1993 to 2014, in both men and women.

The percentage of people reporting severe mental health symptoms in any given week rose ...[text shortened]... f young women reporting common mental health problems has been going up

More relevant stuff

"Mental health problems".

Do you know the causes for them? What's your theory?

Could it be because of moral decline? God forbid! That might just upset your worldview as defined by the prophet google. 🤣

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

08 Jun 22

-1

@josephw said
I doubt it.Crime rates dropped as a result of increased law enforcement.

Do you think, then, that morality has been more or less constant and that variations in levels of violent crime are explained by factors related to law enforcement?