Is someone who sincerely believes that the Christian faith is the only basis for rational thought at an intellectual disadvantage when discussing things with fellow Christians who don't believe that and with non-Christians?

@fmf said
Is someone who sincerely believes that the Christian faith is the only basis for rational thought at an intellectual disadvantage when discussing things with fellow Christians who don't believe that and with non-Christians?

"Presuppositionalism is a school of Christian apologetics that believes the Christian faith is the only basis for rational thought. It presupposes that the Bible is divine revelation and attempts to expose flaws in other worldviews. It claims that apart from presuppositions, one could not make sense of any human experience, and there can be no set of neutral assumptions from which to reason with a non-Christian. Presuppositionalists claim that a Christian cannot consistently declare his belief in the necessary existence of the God of the Bible and simultaneously argue on the basis of a different set of assumptions that God may not exist and Biblical revelation may not be true." [wiki]

@fmf said
"Presuppositionalism is a school of Christian apologetics that believes the Christian faith is the only basis for rational thought. It presupposes that the Bible is divine revelation and attempts to expose flaws in other worldviews. It claims that apart from presuppositions, one could not make sense of any human experience, and there can be no set of neutral assumptions from whic ...[text shortened]... different set of assumptions that God may not exist and Biblical revelation may not be true." [wiki]

@secondson said
Isn't that assumption presuppositional?

Rationality is in the mind, isn't it? If God created the mind of man, then pure rational thought is a derivative of the mind of God, which is expressly revealed in His Word.

Can a rational argument be made that contradicts the mind of God? It can, but will it succeed?

2 Corinthians 10:5
Casting down imaginations, and every h ...[text shortened]... against the knowledge of God, and bringing into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ;

@fmf said
"Presuppositionalism is a school of Christian apologetics that believes the Christian faith is the only basis for rational thought. It presupposes that the Bible is divine revelation and attempts to expose flaws in other worldviews. It claims that apart from presuppositions, one could not make sense of any human experience, and there can be no set of neutral assumptions from whic ...[text shortened]... different set of assumptions that God may not exist and Biblical revelation may not be true." [wiki]

@kellyjay said
No matter what world view is used everyone of them have foundational truth. You think those with only materialistic views don’t view the universe in only a materialistic view point?

@fmf said
Is someone who sincerely believes that the Christian faith is the only basis for rational thought at an intellectual disadvantage when discussing things with fellow Christians who don't believe that and with non-Christians?

@fmf said
The OP question is quite specific and your answer is not contingent upon my opinion about anything. Is your answer to the OP question "Yes" or "No"?

@kellyjay said
Oh please, what a joke from you. I have asked very specific questions and you come back with things like, ",,,what do you mean by reason."

@kellyjay said
Quite specifically, why don't you live by this, answer others the way you want your posts answered.

@fmf said
Yes, that's right. And I explained why. It wasn't a joke. It was going straight to the heart of the bias built into your question. Apparently, you didn't realize.

@fmf said
So, is your answer to the OP question "Yes" or "No"?

@kellyjay said
Zzzzz