Memorable Conversions

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
Why is something evil in the first place? Is it only evil because you decide it is? If you change your mind about something does it's 'evil' status also change?

I've already answered these questions. You must have forgotten.

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
Those actions are all sinful, I may be wrong but I am not in a position to say one sin is worse than another, God will decide.

As you know, I believe that "sin" is something that exists in your mind only and it often has little or nothing to do with morality. If your religious dogma renders you unable to differentiate between the level of "evil" of the murder of millions of people in concentration camps, on one hand, and a man looking lustfully at a woman, on the other, then I think your worldview is incoherent.

Originally posted by FMF
I've already answered these questions. You must have forgotten.

You said something along the lines of something is evil if it causes pain? So is accidentally bumping your arm evil?

Originally posted by FMF
As you know, I believe that "sin" is something that exists in your mind only and it often has little or nothing to do with morality. If your religious dogma renders you unable to differentiate between the level of "evil" of the murder of millions of people in concentration camps, on one hand, and a man looking lustfully at a woman, on the other, then I think your worldview is incoherent.

So tell me what basis do you use to differentiate between different levels of evil?

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
You said something along the lines of something is evil if it causes pain? So is accidentally bumping your arm evil?

No I didn't say that at all. You've just fabricated it. And, no I don't think "accidentally bumping your arm" is "evil".

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
So tell me what basis do you use to differentiate between different levels of evil?

I've already addressed this. You seem to be pretending that you've forgotten.

Originally posted by FMF
No I didn't say that at all. You've just fabricated it. And, no I don't think "accidentally bumping your arm" is "evil".

But you said something is evil if it causes pain?

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
But you said something is evil if it causes pain?

Go back and look through our conversations if your curiosity is genuine. It was in the last few months.

Originally posted by FMF
Go back and look through our conversations if your curiosity is genuine. It was in the last few months.

Which thread? Do you remember what you said?

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
Which thread? Do you remember what you said?

Is trolling a universal truth?

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
Which thread? Do you remember what you said?

It's you who is acting as if he doesn't remember, not me.

Originally posted by divegeester
Is trolling a universal truth?

It seems to be the only truth you know. 😛

Originally posted by Fetchmyjunk
You said something along the lines of something is evil if it causes pain? So is accidentally bumping your arm evil?

If I said "something is evil if it causes pain" or "accidentally bumping your arm [is] evil", find these claims and quote me verbatim.

Originally posted by divegeester to Fetchmyjunk
Is trolling a universal truth?

He just ignores and blanks out what people say and then later pretends that they never said anything ~ or makes up stuff. This question about "evil" is a good example.

Originally posted by FMF
He just ignores and blanks out what people say and then later pretends that they never said anything ~ or makes up stuff. This question about "evil" is a good example.

You expect me to remember every word you said, yet it seems you cannot remember it either.

Here is a question I have never asked you: On what basis do you differentiate between 'good' and 'evil'? If you say that my view is incoherent I assume you think that you hold a more coherent view than mine.