Go back
Is AI conscious?

Is AI conscious?

Debates

1 edit

@AThousandYoung said
Are you suggesting that if a machine could do that it would prove it was conscious?

I don’t think I could come up with an original joke on command. Does that prove something about me?
No, I am not suggesting that. There is no one simple criterion of what constitutes consciousness. What AI can do--mimic, actually--is only one small part of what constitutes consciousness, namely, recursion, linear logical steps with no ambiguity and no gaps. Jokes are one merely example of what machines cannot do, or even mimic, namely, non-linear thinking, what I call leap thinking. Jokes often depend on double-meanings which become apparent only combined with a non-logical leap.

The fact that you personally could not come up with an original joke spontaneously is irrelevant--many people do, indeed many make careers out of it, and the fact other people find this funny is an indicator (not a definition) of consciousness for our species.

A human alone is not conscious, and one raised by wolves has only the consciousness of a wolf; consciousness in humans develops in a socio-linguistic environment. However, putting five computers in a room together still won't make them conscious; they will still be merely mimicking linear-gapless logical steps without knowing what they are mimicking--just as clocks 'tell' us the time without knowing what time it is.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@AThousandYoung said
Normally perceptions and opinions are not considered "feelings" either. You're using that word awfully loosely to the point of meaninglessness.

"How are you feeling Johnny?"

"I'm feeling blue"

"Aww why is that Johnny?"

"Because my eyes are pointed at the sky and blue light is entering them and stimulating my retina so I am feeling the blueness"

????
You seem to be only confusing yourself. We all know what feelings are.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AThousandYoung said
So what's a better analogy for the brain?

I don't know what you mean by current flowing mechanically not electrically. Electrical current in wires is caused by the physical mechanical movement of charged particles called electrons. I guess you're differentiating between the movement of ions vs movement of electrons? Odd way to describe it.
I've written it multiple times on this thread. The mechanisms are completely different, and therefore anthropomorphizing the machine is illogical and dangerous. Let's not treat stuffed animals as if they're real pets.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
I've written it multiple times on this thread. The mechanisms are completely different, and therefore anthropomorphizing the machine is illogical and dangerous. Let's not treat stuffed animals as if they're real pets.
So you don’t have a better analogy but you know that computers aren’t the best analogy.

?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
You seem to be only confusing yourself. We all know what feelings are.
Yes and we all know people sometimes are conscious but feel nothing.

Careful using “what everyone knows” to define scientific concepts.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
I've written it multiple times on this thread. The mechanisms are completely different, and therefore anthropomorphizing the machine is illogical and dangerous. Let's not treat stuffed animals as if they're real pets.
You seem to be confusing consciousness with being human.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
I've written it multiple times on this thread. The mechanisms are completely different, and therefore anthropomorphizing the machine is illogical and dangerous. Let's not treat stuffed animals as if they're real pets.
Airplanes and birds have different mechanisms for flight too. As it turns out you don’t need DNA and muscle cells that change shape to fly. Lord Kelvin was wrong.

And nobody is saying a 747 is a bird.


@AThousandYoung said
You seem to be confusing consciousness with being human.
Not at all. I'm not even saying that a nervous system would be required for consciousness. There are legitimate argument that plants could be conscious, since they feel and adapt and communicate and cooperate and learn and remember. Reactions are stochastic and individualistic and unpredictable. These properties are biological.

Current AI dogma assumes they can work backwards from what causes the emergent property of consciousness by blasting a computer with the entirety of human knowledge and telling it to pretend to be conscious. But that's obviously not going to work.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AThousandYoung said
Airplanes and birds have different mechanisms for flight too. As it turns out you don’t need DNA and muscle cells that change shape to fly. Lord Kelvin was wrong.

And nobody is saying a 747 is a bird.
Nobody is saying computers can't learn to fly. Airplanes aren't conscious.

3 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
Not at all. I'm not even saying that a nervous system would be required for consciousness. There are legitimate argument that plants could be conscious, since they feel and adapt and communicate and cooperate and learn and remember. Reactions are stochastic and individualistic and unpredictable. These properties are biological.

Current AI dogma assumes they can work back ...[text shortened]... f human knowledge and telling it to pretend to be conscious. But that's obviously not going to work.
Plants are conscious now?

They “feel and adapt and communicate and cooperate and learn and remember”?

So a sunflower that turns to face the sun is conscious but a camera with a motor, software and an hard drive isn’t?

Because biology? lol

Does this mean you’re anthropomorphising broccoli?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@AThousandYoung said
Plants are conscious now?

They “feel and adapt and communicate and cooperate and learn and remember”?

So a sunflower that turns to face the sun is conscious but a camera with a motor, software and an hard drive isn’t?

Because biology? lol

Does this mean you’re anthropomorphising broccoli?
Not sure if they are conscious but there is more supportive evidence than computers are conscious.