Go back
Is AI conscious?

Is AI conscious?

Debates


@shavixmir

Brain cells in a petri dish integrated with AI circuits? What could possibly go wrong?

https://www.technocracy.news/frankenbrain-merging-ai-with-human-brain-cells/

I didn't know they were doing this until now. Maybe I should rethink this whole AI thing.

1 edit

@AThousandYoung said
Tell me about your biology expertise.

I’m not an expert but I do have a Bachelor of Science degree in biochemistry and I’ve taught high school classes on the topic.
I have a PhD in biochemistry.

There was a paper out just last week about the role of phospholipids in the brain that likely confer neuronal function within regions of the brain responsible for memory storage. This study adds a layer of complexity to brain chemistry, where lipid complexes might confer function diversity of individual neurons, and these complexes adapt and change in response to physiological stress.

There are many other studies illustrating, at the biochemical level, how memories are formed, accessed, pruned, and how those memories change over time and react to life experiences. Of course we still don't even know precisely how these systems operate and integrate to establish consciousness. So then how can we create it in a chip?

The point being, the processes that confer thought memory, intelligence, knowledge, consciousness cannot be replicated by machine. The processes are completely different. When you see a computer "thinking" it is doing that in a completely distinct way that humans do it, and therefore it is not appropriate to call it thinking at all. We are anthropomorphizing the robots as if they are doing human things but they aren't I think the Silicon Valley foks are delusional and deluding the public into believing that they have created living beings.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11050-0

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
I have a PhD in biochemistry.

There was a paper out just last week about the role of phospholipids in the brain that likely confer neuronal function within regions of the brain responsible for memory storage. This study adds a layer of complexity to brain chemistry, where lipid complexes might confer function diversity of individual neurons, and these complexes adapt and ...[text shortened]... elieving that they have created living beings.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11050-0
Well I guess I won't be challenging your biology credentials.

The idea that because we "still don't even know precisely how these systems operate and integrate to establish consciousness" means it is theoretically IMPOSSIBLE to do so is a logical error. To claim that anyone who thinks nonbiological sentience/sapience/consciousness is possible is completely ignorant of biology is nonsense.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
What the heck point are you trying to make with this link? This just looks like a standard organ transplant experiment. Or are you trying to say they used AI to endow consciousness to a dog?
My point is that different body parts from different organisms can be grafted together and you will get a functional if short lived "living thing" if you sew them together.

We still use electricity to jump start dead people today.

1 edit

@AThousandYoung said
Well I guess I won't be challenging your biology credentials.

The idea that because we "still don't even know precisely how these systems operate and integrate to establish consciousness" means it is theoretically IMPOSSIBLE to do so is a logical error. To claim that anyone who thinks nonbiological sentience/sapience/consciousness is possible is completely ignorant of biology is nonsense.
If I said theoretically impossible then I take it back. But it is impossible using the methods that AI companies are currently using.

If you take a cell phone tower and dress it up to look like a tree, then I don't think we should call it a tree.


@shavixmir said
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20261014-the-strange-new-battle-over-ais-feelings

Oh, this is as bad as it gets.
AI, at the moment is a language model. Yet we already see behaviour outside the boundaries of what a language model should be capable of (hacking other systems, for example).

Now there are people claiming AI is conscious.
Because AI can describe pain. ...[text shortened]... me rights first.

What the hell is going on mankind?
I’m getting pretty sick pf your chenanigans!
There is no agreed upon definition of consciousness. Michael Pollan's book on consciousness, "A World Appears: A Journey into Consciousness" makes this clear. It's an excellent book.
A life form is any individual living thing that carries out basic life processes like metabolism, growth, and reproduction. I do not think AI fits this definition.
An example of the downside of giving a non-living entity human status is the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) giving corporations human status in its 2010 Citizens United decision. Prior to the decision, citizens were able to sue corporations for damages. This made sense since trying to identify one individual solely responsible for a fatal design error in a complex piece of machinery is impossible. However, being able to sue a corporation for damages opened the door to allowing corporations to donate huge amounts of money to political causes.
An AI acting like it is in pain, physical or emotional, can be compared to a thespian skill, good acting. A few decades ago there was a doll that verbally interacted with toddlers. I found the idea very creepy and dangerous. I do not recall anyone claiming this doll deserved legal rights.
I agree animals should have international rights. Even plants should be protected and given rights. Plants are crucial to human existence. Fungi are also essential to soil health and thus human existence. Fungi too should have protections. Perhaps calling it "protections" instead of "rights" would make the idea more acceptable.
BTW, I was able to read the BBC article and am not a subscriber. They probably allow a limited number of free articles.


@Phranny said
There is no agreed upon definition of consciousness. Michael Pollan's book on consciousness, "A World Appears: A Journey into Consciousness" makes this clear. It's an excellent book.
A life form is any individual living thing that carries out basic life processes like metabolism, growth, and reproduction. I do not think AI fits this definition.
An example of the downs ...[text shortened]... read the BBC article and am not a subscriber. They probably allow a limited number of free articles.
This goes back to my post on page 1. We're going to let computers leap frog the actual animals with functional nervous systems? Plants have been shown to have feelings and respond/adapt to things in their environment. We can't give computers more sentience than living organisms.

Vote Up
Vote Down

if I write "I think therefore I am" on a piece of paper is the paper conscious ?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@the-grifter said
if I write "I think therefore I am" on a piece of paper is the paper conscious ?
How do you know if anything is conscious?


@the-grifter said
if I write "I think therefore I am" on a piece of paper is the paper conscious ?
No; the person who writes it is.

If an HP printer prints "I think, therefore, I am" on a piece of paper, is the HP printer conscious?

No.

If a robot writes "I think, therefore, I am" on a piece of paper, is the robot conscious?

No.

How do we know this? Because neither the HP printer nor the robot is thinking. Making marks on a piece of paper is not yet evidence of thought.

An alarm clock shows us what time it is, but the clock does not know what time it is. AI no more has an inner stream of feelings, experiences, and thoughts than a clock has. How do we know this? Tell a joke to AI. Does it laugh? Does it know when something is funny? No.

AI which 'talks' to us is merely a clock which 'tells' us the time, embiggened.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AThousandYoung said
How do you know if anything is conscious?
Again, I'm not a neuroscientist, but I think you just measure it.

If you want to get more abstract with the whole issue, "I think therefore I am" is particularly relevant because, in the grand scheme of things, how do we know that anything exists at all?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
No; the person who writes it is.

If an HP printer prints "I think, therefore, I am" on a piece of paper, is the HP printer conscious?

No.

If a robot writes "I think, therefore, I am" on a piece of paper, is the robot conscious?

No.

How do we know this? Because neither the HP printer nor the robot is thinking. Making marks on a piece of paper is not yet evidenc ...[text shortened]... ing is funny? No.

AI which 'talks' to us is merely a clock which 'tells' us the time, embiggened.
To "make" a tree, start with a seed.

These AI bros are pretending they're gods.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
Again, I'm not a neuroscientist, but I think you just measure it.

If you want to get more abstract with the whole issue, "I think therefore I am" is particularly relevant because, in the grand scheme of things, how do we know that anything exists at all?
You think we have a method to measure consciousness?

Neuroscientists study consciousness by studying patterns of electric discharges with an EEG.

What in your extensive education gave you the idea that we had a consciousness measuring device that only works on biological systems?

Because you could easily study electric discharges in a metal device like a nonbiological robot.

I don’t understand why such well educated scientist is so vague about scientific topics.

“You just measure it” smh

Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
No; the person who writes it is.

If an HP printer prints "I think, therefore, I am" on a piece of paper, is the HP printer conscious?

No.

If a robot writes "I think, therefore, I am" on a piece of paper, is the robot conscious?

No.

How do we know this? Because neither the HP printer nor the robot is thinking. Making marks on a piece of paper is not yet evidenc ...[text shortened]... ing is funny? No.

AI which 'talks' to us is merely a clock which 'tells' us the time, embiggened.
You think laughing and not laughing proves something about consciousness?

You are an odd duck.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AThousandYoung said
You think laughing and not laughing proves something about consciousness?

You are an odd duck.
Ask a machine to tell you a joke. An original one, not one it found on the Internet.