15 Mar 08
Originally posted by FreakyKBH
No matter where you look, you will find the same answer, i.e., it is a process. That leaves the same question still sitting there, doesn't it?
This says process, not act. They are not synonymous. The acts in question are the reproductive
acts. The influences are whether the reproducers are going to be more or less likely to reproduce
(based on their survivability).
I used the word 'mechanism' before, or 'description.' Process is a better word, I suppose, largely
because I would hope it would help to compel the reader to stop thinking of NS as a force
that acts upon a species. Somehow this is not the case with you.
Nemesio
18 Mar 08
Originally posted by NemesioIt shouldn't be lost on you, yet it is. Curious. Let's play a little game, then, shall we? Regarding the cellular process known as photosynthesis, a plant contains photosynthetic cells. Since NS is said to occur at the cellular level, which of the living organisms on the planet can be rightly said to have NS cells?
Originally posted by FreakyKBH
[b]No matter where you look, you will find the same answer, i.e., it is a process. That leaves the same question still sitting there, doesn't it?
This says process, not act. They are not synonymous. The acts in question are the reproductive
acts. The influences are whether the reproducers are going to be mor ...[text shortened]... S as a force
that acts upon a species. Somehow this is not the case with you.
Nemesio[/b]
18 Mar 08
Originally posted by FreakyKBHNatural selection occurs at the species level. You are either misstating, misunderstanding, or
Since NS is said to occur at the cellular level, which of the living organisms on the planet can be rightly said to have NS cells?
misquoting whatever source to which you are trying to appeal.
NS isn't a property of cells.
Nemesio
18 Mar 08
Originally posted by FreakyKBHEvery organism on the planet has naturally selected cells.
It shouldn't be lost on you, yet it is. Curious. Let's play a little game, then, shall we? Regarding the cellular process known as photosynthesis, a plant contains photosynthetic cells. Since NS is said to occur at the cellular level, which of the living organisms on the planet can be rightly said to have NS cells?
19 Mar 08
Originally posted by FreakyKBHI refer you to my second post in the thread:
Again, you challenge bereft of weight. I have read each and every post within the thread. The best that has been offered--- and even that without agreement--- is what NS does, not what it is. Give it a shot, though, since you think yourself up to the task. What is NS?
In nature, (ie amongst living things not deliberately being bread by man), there are a number of factors which result in selective breeding. There are a vast number of these factors ranging from environmental effects to the behavior or characteristics of the individuals. The overall result of these effects is referred to as 'Natural Selection'.
As yet, I do not think you have challenged that definition nor asked for clarification, yet you repeatedly claim that nobody has defined Natural Selection.
Just to expand on the definition above, 'Natural Selection' can also be used to describe a similar effect on any set of replicating entities, including non-life, or components of life.
Keep in mind that you cannot claim my definition is wrong, as it is a definition and hence has no truth value. The best you can do to challenge it is to claim that it is non-standard ie does not match the definition used by others.
20 Mar 08
1 edit
Originally posted by twhiteheadYou're right: your definition may need a second look. Give me a few days and I'll respond.
I refer you to my second post in the thread:
In nature, (ie amongst living things not deliberately being bread by man), there are a number of factors which result in selective breeding. There are a vast number of these factors ranging from environmental effects to the behavior or characteristics of the individuals. The overall result of these effect enge it is to claim that it is non-standard ie does not match the definition used by others.