Question for Atheists

Question for Atheists

Spirituality

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
22 Feb 07

Originally posted by twhitehead
Because of the amount of evidence for it and the lack of evidence against it. Why?
Reproducible evidence?

BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
22 Feb 07

Originally posted by dj2becker
You mean [b]absolutely morally correct?[/b]
Sure.

j

Joined
02 Aug 06
Moves
12622
23 Feb 07
1 edit

Originally posted by scottishinnz
This has [b]absolutely nothing to do with the topic of this thread.[/b]
I thought the topic was "Question for Atheists".

s
Kichigai!

Osaka

Joined
27 Apr 05
Moves
8592
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by jaywill
I thought the topic was "Question for Atheists".
Yes. Question. Not Questions. The opening post was on whether or not morals are absolute, and that has nothing to do with whether a factual statement is true or not.

j

Joined
02 Aug 06
Moves
12622
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by scottishinnz
Yes. Question. Not Question[b]s. The opening post was on whether or not morals are absolute, and that has nothing to do with whether a factual statement is true or not.[/b]
Oh. Where was your answer?

s
Kichigai!

Osaka

Joined
27 Apr 05
Moves
8592
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by jaywill
Oh. Where was your answer?
About a dozen pages back.

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by twhitehead
No, statements about facts are true or not. We could however call a fact a truth, but that is a result of the flexibility of the English language.

In English 'fact' can mean an actual fact or a statement about fact so it gets rather confusing.
No, statements about facts are true or not.

So if the statements about the facts are true does not mean the facts are also true?

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by Starrman
No. Facts, as opposed to relations of ideas in a Humean sense, are observable, contingent, emprircal entities. As such they are only confirmed by probability and repetition. As far as I am concerned, the perseverence of factual knowledge is inductive in basis and as such is relative to experience.
Is reality aboslutely real?

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
Sure.
Would you mind explaining why this is the case?

S

Joined
19 Nov 03
Moves
31382
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by dj2becker
Is reality aboslutely real?
What a stupid question. Do they actually teach you this crud, or are you thinking for yourself?

What is reality and what is real are one and the same thing, idiot.

M

Joined
23 Feb 07
Moves
244
23 Feb 07

I guess that would depend on if you believe murder is absolutely wrong. In order for something to be absolutely wrong, there would have to be a higher order or law stating so. I can't think of any higher order or law that atheists belive in. I am not a self proclaimed atheist but I would think an atheist would adhere to a more relativistic approach to a deviant act. That is he would interpret circumstances such as: does it go against societies norms (in the case of murder yes), was there a reaction to it (becasue some atheists would believe if nobody finds out, then its not wrong), or if someone were to find out, then would it be considered wrong. I think an atheist would think about these things in order to determine wrongness so no, a true atheist does not think murder is absolutely wrong.

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by Starrman
What a stupid question. Do they actually teach you this crud, or are you thinking for yourself?

What is reality and what is real are one and the same thing, idiot.
And you are absolutely 100% sure about, suddenly?

BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by dj2becker
Would you mind explaining why this is the case?
OK. Would God ever command somebody to do something immoral?

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
OK. Would God ever command somebody to do something immoral?
When is something judged to be immoral?

s

Joined
23 Sep 05
Moves
11774
23 Feb 07

Originally posted by dj2becker
When is something judged to be immoral?
Are you saying that nothing is immoral, that you don't know what immoral is,
or that we can't know what is immoral?