01 Dec '22 10:06>
@metal-brain saidThis was the first I heard of this, so coming here to this board is my version of fact checking.🧐
@KellyJay
I don't think the info provided in the video you posted is accurate. Look up MoND Theory (modified Newtonian dynamics). Assuming the measurement of the speed of stars is accurate the laws of gravity as we know them must be incomplete. If there is a disagreement as to the speed of stars in a galaxy I would like to know about it. That should be addressed first.
@sonhouse saidThe possibilities that may or may not true as a result of any hypothesis is not a means of validation. Simply because something may have worldview ramifications is beside the point, is it true should be the only criteria of consequence
@KellyJay
This should not even be in science since it is at the bottom, a religious argument about the age of the universe. Saying we should not be able to see galaxies as spiral is a specious argument designed to try to convince people the biblical version of creation is correct and ALL of science is wrong.
For one thing, he keeps saying the universe is 10 billion years ...[text shortened]... e as science?
It is at best an opinion piece because there is ZERO science behind this hypothesis.
@sonhouse saidIt may have implications that lean that way, but you are the only one here making
@KellyJay
You can talk all you want, it still is a religious argument and not a field of science. For one thing, there is no way of disproving any of it, making it go against the Popper theory, it has to be able to be falsified, if not, it is religious and not science.
@sonhouse saidAgain you are the only one here judging the truthfulness because of how it affects your world view.
@KellyJay
Come on, it is obviously religiously based scree, they want to show GOD is responsible for the universe or some such. The whole universe thing is freaky to me, billions of galaxies with billions of stars in each one and now the Webb telescope seeing them out almost to the edge of what is visible. It makes humans like a little virus on the scale of the universe but ...[text shortened]... to try to prove your god is real.
THAT IS THE BOTTOM LINE IN THAT LINK AND YOU KNOW THAT FULL WELL.