Originally posted by Dasa
1 week after conception the baby does not look like a baby, and looks more like a walnut.

But we all know that this walnut is on its way to becoming a baby...........don't we?

This is what is the unmanifest baby.

Its there but it isn't there.

No, I do not know that a walnut becomes a baby.

Originally posted by DeepThought
As a working definition, and since the various theists are somewhat coy about giving one, I'm going to define the soul to be a non-physical entity which somehow contains the essence of who we are and may exist independently of the body.

There are two possibilities, either we have souls or we do not. If we do not have souls then as a matter of observa ...[text shortened]... most theists are talking about. I therefore do not think that you have shown that souls exist.

The mind is immaterial, while the brain is material. 😏

Originally posted by RJHinds
The mind is immaterial, while the brain is material. 😏

Well, take away the material part of the brain and what do you have?

Originally posted by sonhouse
Well, take away the material part of the brain and what do you have?

I believe it would be called a dead body. 😏

Originally posted by RJHinds
I believe it would be called a dead body. 😏

So you have no way to prove what you just said. No wait, you will just post a video of someone ELSE's thoughts, god forbid you use your own brain, such as it is.

Originally posted by sonhouse
So you have no way to prove what you just said. No wait, you will just post a video of someone ELSE's thoughts, god forbid you use your own brain, such as it is.

Actually sonhouse, I think you do Mr Hinds a great disservice, he is living proof that intelligent design cannot possibly exist!

Originally posted by sonhouse
So you have no way to prove what you just said. No wait, you will just post a video of someone ELSE's thoughts, god forbid you use your own brain, such as it is.

What Can You Do Without a Brain?

YouTube

Originally posted by RJHinds
What Can You Do Without a Brain?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3teflb1QNN4

I'm shocked. Ok, its someone else's thought but you actually posted a rational video? Will wonders never cease.

Originally posted by RJHinds
No, I do not know that a walnut becomes a baby.

What on earth are you talking about?????????????????

Are you seriously confused? .....because if you are I cannot help you.

Originally posted by Dasa
What on earth are you talking about?????????????????

Are you seriously confused? .....because if you are I cannot help you.

You cannot help him anyway. Take your false religion and go.

Originally posted by DeepThought
As a working definition, and since the various theists are somewhat coy about giving one, I'm going to define the soul to be a non-physical entity which somehow contains the essence of who we are and may exist independently of the body.

There are two possibilities, either we have souls or we do not. If we do not have souls then as a matter of observa ...[text shortened]... most theists are talking about. I therefore do not think that you have shown that souls exist.

You are a sharp pencil.

Sadly your sharp wit is wasted on over analyzing that which is beyond mundane perception.

The soul [you] cannot be perceived by mundane perception.

However when the mind and heart are purified by engaging in Bhakti Yoga or Krsna Consciousness / then and only then will you be able to perceive that which is unperceivable.

Dont let your strong intelligence over analyze everything..............and then miss the mark.

And are you aware that the game "chess" was first discovered and played in the Vedas.

The Supreme Personality of "Godhead Krsna" is fond of playing the eternal game of chess.

Originally posted by Suzianne
You cannot help him anyway. Take your false religion and go.

Hey, hey .... !!!

that's not nice.

And anyway, I reckon his religion is better than yours 😛

Originally posted by Dasa
You are a sharp pencil.

Sadly your sharp wit is wasted on over analyzing that which is beyond mundane perception.

The soul [you] cannot be perceived by mundane perception.

However when the mind and heart are purified by engaging in Bhakti Yoga or Krsna Consciousness / then and only then will you be able to perceive that which is unperceivable.

Dont ...[text shortened]... das.

The Supreme Personality of "Godhead Krsna" is fond of playing the eternal game of chess.

So you think RJ should think more and that I should think less?

Originally posted by RJHinds
As I understand it, microbes are tiny organisms that often exist in water and can act as parasites on plants and animals. So they seem to only effect the plant and animal bodies, which are material. The soul and spirit of man is believed by theologians to be immaterial.

I am not sure anyone could give a definition for the immaterial that everyone could e ...[text shortened]... but you will be you. [/quote]
http://www.comereason.org/difference-between-soul-and-spirit.asp

I like this one!

Originally posted by RJHinds
The body would collapse as if knocked unconscience.

The lights would be on, but no one would be home.