Are catholics christians???

Are catholics christians???

Spirituality

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Zellulärer Automat

Spiel des Lebens

Joined
27 Jan 05
Moves
90892
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by lucifershammer
The term 'Christian' has a well-understood (if not well-articulated) meaning that is more than just "anyone who calls himself a Christian".
Wouldn't mind if you articulated it a bit.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by Bosse de Nage
Wouldn't mind if you articulated it a bit.
To some extent I did in my previous post.

Just because a perfect verbal definition cannot be provided for something doesn't mean people can't generally identify what it is.

Zellulärer Automat

Spiel des Lebens

Joined
27 Jan 05
Moves
90892
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by lucifershammer
To some extent I did in my previous post.

Just because a perfect verbal definition cannot be provided for something doesn't mean people can't generally identify what it is.
Like "spiritual growth", eh? OK.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by Bosse de Nage
Like "spiritual growth", eh?
Actually, no. See my last post on the other thread.

Zellulärer Automat

Spiel des Lebens

Joined
27 Jan 05
Moves
90892
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by lucifershammer
Actually, no. See my last post on the other thread.
Have it your way.

Hmmm . . .

Joined
19 Jan 04
Moves
22131
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by lucifershammer
What about the Christians who were around before the Bible?
And all those around before Luther’s doctrine of sola scriptura (16th century), and all those who are not now sola scripturists...

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
31 Oct 06

"Christian", to me, means Christ-like. The suffix -ian meaning from, related to, or resembling. A Christian is someone who exhibits the characteristics of Jesus Christ - compassionate, merciful, loving, etc. Are all Catholics Christians? Certainly not, in my opinion. I know Buddhists who are better Christians than some Catholic priests.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
31 Oct 06
3 edits

Originally posted by darvlay
"Christian", to me, means Christ-like. The suffix -ian meaning from, related to, or resembling. A Christian is someone who exhibits the characteristics of Jesus Christ - compassionate, merciful, loving, etc. Are all Catholics Christians? Certainly not, in my opinion. I know Buddhists who are better Christians than some Catholic priests.
That is one dictionary definition of Christian (e.g. "Christian living" or "Christian virtue" ).

Presumably the discussion here revolves around demographic or sociological definitions.

EDIT: Also, I feel that the image of Christ's compassion, mercy, love, forgiveness etc. is often misunderstood as some kind of infinite tolerance.

g
Wayward Soul

Your Blackened Sky

Joined
12 Mar 02
Moves
15128
31 Oct 06

catholic church=the church of christ. the roman catholic one is the one which we are discussing and most people assumed this. the christian creed mentions of catholic church. pretty much every church is catholic, by definition. if it's not catholic then it is not "of christ" thus it is not christian...

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by lucifershammer
That is one dictionary definition of Christian (e.g. "Christian living" or "Christian virtue" ).

Presumably the discussion here revolves around demographic or sociological definitions.

EDIT: Also, I feel that the image of Christ's compassion, mercy, love, forgiveness etc. is often misunderstood.
I think that specific dictionary definition is the closest to the biblical definition of a Christian.

Demographic Christian? 😕

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by genius
catholic church=the church of christ. the roman catholic one is the one which we are discussing and most people assumed this. the christian creed mentions of catholic church. pretty much every church is catholic, by definition. if it's not catholic then it is not "of christ" thus it is not christian...
Huh?

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by lucifershammer
Also, I feel that the image of Christ's compassion, mercy, love, forgiveness etc. is often misunderstood as some kind of infinite tolerance.
I agree. Christ wasn't very tolerant of the Pharisees.

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by lucifershammer
Huh?
I was wondering the same thing...

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by darvlay
I think that specific dictionary definition is the closest to the biblical definition of a Christian.

Demographic Christian? 😕
Christian for demographic purposes (e.g. census).

The word "Christian" is mentioned in the NT three times (Acts 11:26, Acts 26:28 and 1 Peter 4:16). In all three cases, a demographic/sociological/religiously formal definition is implied. While being Christ-like is exhorted of them, it is not presumed.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
31 Oct 06

Originally posted by darvlay
I agree. Christ wasn't very tolerant of the Pharisees.
More than that. Christ did not simply hand out forgiveness or healing or teaching or grace willy-nilly. There is always an implicit or explicit "challenge" or "hurdle" that the recepient has to address.