- Joined
- 29 Dec 08
- Moves
- 6788
I'd put this in the chess forum but I might get jumped on for it not being about chess as played.
Suppose you are playing as black, but there is a rule change -- black has to decide their first move without knowing what white's first move is. From that point on, play is normal. You don't have to disclose your first move until white has moved, but you have to pre-commit. What move will you make, and why?
Now, suppose you are white, playing under the above rule change. Before you play your first move, you are thinking about what black's pre-committed first move might be. Will it affect your choice of first move? If so, what will be your first move, and why?
Of course, black knows white is thinking about this, and so on...
Another way to answer these questions, if you prefer, is, what commonly used first moves will you definitely NOT make?
How do you think this rule change would affect the game -- would some openings go out of style, would white have an significant advantage, etc.?
Originally posted by JS357This is like Kriegspiel chess, several versions, one where you put up a barrier between your half and the opponents half of the board and you both move then move the barrier, which you could do in your variant after the first move.
I'd put this in the chess forum but I might get jumped on for it not being about chess as played.
Suppose you are playing as black, but there is a rule change -- black has to decide their first move without knowing what white's first move is. From that point on, play is normal. You don't have to disclose your first move until white has moved, but you have t ...[text shortened]... ame -- would some openings go out of style, would white have an significant advantage, etc.?
My idea would be just to move out a knight, there would be no instant takes as opposed to pushing a pawn up two, the other side could have moved its pawns up two and then a take could happen.
Moving a knight out, either one, would stop an instant take.
Originally posted by JS3571 ... Nf6
I'd put this in the chess forum but I might get jumped on for it not being about chess as played.
Suppose you are playing as black, but there is a rule change -- black has to decide their first move without knowing what white's first move is. From that point on, play is normal. You don't have to disclose your first move until white has moved, but you have t ...[text shortened]... ame -- would some openings go out of style, would white have an significant advantage, etc.?
Doesnt matter what white plays first.
1 ... e5 is a no no.
Taking your idea one step further what if before seeing blacks move white had to write down his 2nd? and before seeing white's 2nd move black had to write down his reply? et cetera.
Originally posted by wolfgang59In one version of kreigspiel, you put the barrier up between the white and black side of the board and play X amount of moves behind your lines, then take away the barrier, and play from there, white moves first. You basically set up a position you think will counter whatever blind position the opponent has set up. All the pawns on the 4th rank, rooks right behind, king in the corner, whatever.
1 ... Nf6
Doesnt matter what white plays first.
1 ... e5 is a no no.
Taking your idea one step further what if before seeing blacks move white had to write down his 2nd? and before seeing white's 2nd move black had to write down his reply? et cetera.
Originally posted by sonhouseyesI've played various kriegspiel versions. What I am proposing is qite different though as each player sees the board except without their opponents last move.
In one version of kreigspiel, you put the barrier up between the white and black side of the board and play X amount of moves behind your lines, then take away the barrier, and play from there, white moves first. You basically set up a position you think will counter whatever blind position the opponent has set up. All the pawns on the 4th rank, rooks right behind, king in the corner, whatever.
- Joined
- 29 Dec 08
- Moves
- 6788
Originally posted by wolfgang591...Nf6 looks best. I think you are correct about 1...e4 but if white thinks black is a rational player, white thinks black will not stupidly play 1...e5, so white won't give preference to 1. Nf3 or d4. But they are decent moves regardless.
1 ... Nf6
Doesnt matter what white plays first.
1 ... e5 is a no no.
Taking your idea one step further what if before seeing blacks move white had to write down his 2nd? and before seeing white's 2nd move black had to write down his reply? et cetera.
On your suggestion to pre-commit on each move, the trick is how to deal with an illegal pre-committed move. Would it be a loss?
- Joined
- 18 Jan 07
- Moves
- 12466
Originally posted by wolfgang59That's somewhat (but not greatly) suspect if White plays 1. e4. The Alekine is certainly playable, but it has to fit one's style to begin with.If you don't know how to handle it, it can be a hassle.
1 ... Nf6
Doesnt matter what white plays first.
My suggestion would be 1. ... d5. The worst possibility that I can see is, again, 1. e4, but theory for the Scandiwegian has been growing apace the last few years, and many people consider the new (or rather, renewed) lines playable for Black. Similar setups ought to work against 1. c4.
Richard
e4 d5 isnt so bad.
i play it sometimes in my games and it goes something like exd5 qxd5 nc3 qa5...
if i was black i would play d5 or nf6. for white...i wouldnt bother thinking about it. nothing changes for white, so i would play e4.
(another way to put this problem is that black makes one ive, then white gets two in a row, right?)
- Joined
- 18 Jan 07
- Moves
- 12466
Originally posted by Banana KingAnother decent move would be 1. ... c5. With e4, you get the Sicilian, which is a bonus. With d4, the Benoni, which is playable. With b4, well, who cares? And with anything else, it's decent enough.
e4 d5 isnt so bad.
i play it sometimes in my games and it goes something like exd5 qxd5 nc3 qa5...
if i was black i would play d5 or nf6. for white...i wouldnt bother thinking about it. nothing changes for white, so i would play e4.
(another way to put this problem is that black makes one ive, then white gets two in a row, right?)
Richard
