I used to play the 3...Ng4 line, probably played around thirty serious games with it in all, and the problem I had was that in too many games White managed to swap off a few pieces leaving him with a small, but undeniable, advantage.

If you want to live dangerously learn the Englund Gambit - 1.d4 e5! It's terrible, but there's just one spectacularly winning line for Black which may occur once every ten games and makes the nine previous losses worthwhile!

Originally posted by XanthosNZ
Whether according to current theory and best play the opening will give good results.

Any small advantage white may get from the BloodyPest, (or any other opening considered a bit unsound in theory), at most levels of play, is offset by the fact that Black is likely to be much more familiar with the sort of positions which will occur.