12 Oct 11
Originally posted by Shallow BlueSo high-diving, surfing and trampoulining are all performance art and Scrabble is a sport?
If you need a judge, who puts a (often highly personal) value on a performance, it's not a sport but a performance art.
In sports, you have rules which decide who wins, not opinions. Of course one can differ in opinion on whether a certain decision by a referee was correct or not, but when you get down to it, that decision either was or was not corr ...[text shortened]... chwalbe was worth 7.4 points"; it was a matter of "This was/was not a schwalbe".
Richard
Defining sport is a tricky one but i think your definition is too narrow.
btw: I am a dancer and my dancing is neither sport nor art! 😀
- Joined
- 18 Jan 07
- Moves
- 12466
13 Oct 11
Originally posted by wolfgang59Yes, yes, yes, (all currently - in theory, they could be organised as sports, although at least diving and trampolining aren't likely to) and no. My statement was intended as a required, not necessary sufficient, condition. (Although, if one wants, one can define both Scrabble and chess as mental sports. And not without justification.)
So high-diving, surfing and trampoulining are all performance art and Scrabble is a sport?
Richard