I was never quite sure about EvRyDay. He didn't post to the forums much, and when he did it tended to be complete rubbish - his analysis of a game he had won was really weird. He claimed to have beaten an IM when he'd only been playing chess for "a little over a year". I suspect he was a real player, but not particularly strong. Certainly not strong enough to support the massive rating he achieved on this site. He hasn't been banned so I guess I'd better leave it at that. On the other hand, several people I have spoken to about EvRyDay thought he was a legitimate player.