10 Oct '19 11:53>
@fmf saidNo, you weren't. You were attacking me. As usual.
I was responding to what DeepThought had put to you.
@fmf saidNo, you weren't. You were attacking me. As usual.
I was responding to what DeepThought had put to you.
@fmf saidI have no idea.
What is the extent of the correlation, in your view, between "Narcissistic Personality Disorder" and what you refer to as "an alpha personality"? What proportion of the latter do you think might be diagnosed with "NPD"?
@fmf saidEnough to establish a "type". While rare, it is not at all unknown.
Approximately what proportion of adult males do you perceive as being "alpha" type?
@fmf saidOnce you told me it was sonship, I was surprised that he had said those exact words (even though, again, I have no proof, only your say so), but it doesn't seem out of character for him.
Will you be asking sonship this too? He seems to correlate atheism with what he calls "malignant self-love". On page 1 you seemed on the verge of saying something by way of objection to it, but then you realized it was sonship who'd said it.
@divegeester saidI think it was probably ill-informed and was not something I would have said.
What do you think of the OP especially in light of it being a Christian here he used the term as an insult?
@suzianne saidBut it wasn't me who said sonship has malignant self-love; it was sonship who said I have malignant self-love ...because I am an atheist. You have got who "attacked" whom the wrong way round.
Knowing your character, as evidenced in this forum and elsewhere on this site, I would also not be surprised if you have made the entire quote out of thin air. You excel at "making mountains out of molehills" on this site, particularly in your attacks on people you do not like, or who have rather vociferously disagreed with you in the past. I have personal experience of this.
@suzianne saidI said "I think Suzianne is conflating 'narcissism' with 'NPD'." How is that "attacking" you? It's just a difference of opinion. "Narcissism" is essentially a personality trait seen in many people [as is the 'alpha' characteristic]; NPD is a mental disorder that afflicts a tiny proportion. It's an error to conflate "narcissism" and NPD.
No, you weren't. You were attacking me. As usual.
@suzianne saidCharacterizing atheism as "malignant self-love" struck me as quite interesting. Judging by your reaction to it, and how much you have now posted on this thread, it seems you found it interesting too.
Overall, the topic seems completely unimportant to me. Okay, he said it. So what? It doesn't seem like a big deal. One might think that those who do not believe in God could put their big-boy pants on and blow off something like this. That you instead HAVE to make a "big deal" out of it showcases your own insecurity, IMHO.
@suzianne saidI’m not expecting you to fight my battles for me, why on earth would I expect that?
I think it was probably ill-informed and was not something I would have said.
That being said, sonship IS his own person, and so should not be required to answer to me about his opinions. My personal "How much do I care?" answer about this topic hovers in the single-digit percentages. And no, I'm not going to fight your perceived forum battles for you. I'm sure you can h ...[text shortened]... ch about it. Whether you want to or not, is of course only important to you. Knock yourselves out.
@fmf saidIn a thread over in debates Suzianne said something to the effect of: "Everyone has some level of narcissism.". Which is correct, within normal ranges it comes under the heading of "healthy self-esteem" or "self-respect". With none at all one wouldn't get out of bed. The psychologists talk about high trait narcissism in people where it is starting to push out of normal ranges. NPD is an extreme manifestation of this.
I was responding to what DeepThought had put to you.
@suzianne saidThanks for getting back, see the above post.
Considering that your original post in this thread was about other topics of "pop" psychology, I assumed you would be familiar with the concept of the "alpha" personality. It is basically taking an idea which is prevalent in the field of Ethology, pack dominance, and attributing it to humans. This is really not a topic seriously considered in psychology, but since you went ...[text shortened]... return is "Huh? What do you mean?"
My response wasn't "all that" anyways. Forget I mentioned it.
@suzianne saidI don't think this is right. High trait narcissism, including NPD, is caused by childhood experiences, including parenting errors. I imagine it becomes excessive as a defence against emotional abuse of the type described in the video I posted earlier in the thread. The guy is not an alpha male but has an NPD diagnosis. I don't think that there's that strong a correlation between social status and excessive personality traits.
I have no idea.
All I know is that the two are similar enough that once one is found, the other is often (again, not always) not all that far behind. And before you pounce, no, I have no "evidence" of this, it's just my own personal observation.
Per your own classic style, I realize these questions are just a delaying tactic until you can marshall your forces to attempt another character assassination attempt. Whatever.
@suzianne saidhttps://www.redhotpawn.com/forum/spirituality/the-value-of-jesus.182594/page-4#post_4102733
Has someone in this forum actually said this?